October 16th, 2008

Concept Revision: Timeframe

So, after getting some feedback regarding the timeline and placement of the project, I’m going to go ahead with the identification of the key issues to focus on, and how to relate them back to useful communications for everyday folks. For the next little while at least, that will leave the audience question a bit open, but the materials could be adapted to both approaches. For instance, a poster meant to be developed for the “future” concept, could be implanted into an image for a present day campaign, so that we could see a view of things to come.
To make things nice and simple, the two frameworks will be called 2008 and 2018 from now on, or untilI get better names for them.

Potential Deliverables for 2018
Posters: Messages urging citizens to conserve resources, utilize carbon neutral technologies, drive less, support mass transit, etc.
Billboards: Similar content to posters. Less text, harder imagery.
Website: Provides actual resources on how to conserve, etc.

Potential Deliverables for 2008
Posters: Depictions of a future where government propaganda covers the walls of buildings and other surfaces with messages urging citizens to conserve resources, utilize carbon neutral technologies, drive less, support mass transit, etc.
Billboards: Similar content to posters. Less text, harder imagery.
Website: Interactive site serves a government resource platform done in future style.
Mailers: Ration books detailing month’s rations for citizens under the new legislations. The rations would indicate the scarce supply of resources available for purchase in order to highlight the need for conservation now.

October 9th, 2008

Potential Deliverable: Ration Cards

So, during times of economic crisis, or shortage of resources, one policy that governments use to control the distribution of goods, and ensure that all citizens have access to resources is rationing. “Each person may be given “ration coupons” allowing him or her to purchase a certain amount of a product each month. Rationing often includes food and other necessities for which there is a shortage, including materials needed for the war effort such as rubber tires, leather shoes, clothing and gasoline. Towards the end of the First World War, panic buying in the United Kingdom prompted rationing of first sugar, then meat, for the rest of the war. During World War II rationing existed in many countries including the United Kingdom and the United States.” [wikipedia]


The United States is a key example of rationing in support of the war effort.
“To get a classification and rationing stamps, one had to appear before a local War Price and Rationing Board which reported to the U.S. Office of Price Administration. Each person in a household received a ration book, including babies and small children who qualified for canned milk not available to others. To receive a gasoline ration card, a person had to certify a need for gas and ownership of no more than five tires. All tires in excess of five per driver were confiscated by the government, because of rubber shortages. An A sticker on a car was the lowest priority of gas rationing and entitled the car owner to 3 to 4 gallons of gas per week. B stickers were issued to workers in the military industry, entitling their holder up to 8 gallons of gas per week. C stickers were granted to persons deemed very essential to the war effort, such as doctors. T rations were made available for truckers. Lastly, X stickers on cars entitled the holder to unlimited supplies and were the highest priority in the system. Ministers of Religion, police, firemen, and civil defense workers were in this category.[2] A scandal erupted when 200 Congressmen received these X stickers.[citation needed]

Tires were the first item to be rationed in January 1942 because supplies of natural rubber were interrupted. Soon afterward, passenger automobiles, typewriters, sugar, gasoline, bicycles, footwear, fuel oil, coffee, stoves, shoes, meat, lard, shortening and oils, cheese, butter, margarine, processed foods (canned, bottled and frozen), dried fruits, canned milk, firewood and coal, jams, jellies and fruit butter, were rationed by November 1943.[3] [wikipedia]

The format of a ration book/card may be a potentially effective method for conveying an sense of the situation to come. The piece, which would likely take the form of a card or mailer, would be a ration card for a month in the year 2018 indicating the available allotment of resources which are currently under threat, such as gasoline, water, electricity, foods, etc. The notion being that people will be able to see the result of dwindling resources in a format that would directly apply to their everyday lives. One of the main potential drawbacks of this approach may be a unfamiliarity amongst people today with rationing and how a ration book would work.

Functionality:
“Each ration stamp had a generic drawing of an airplane, gun, tank, aircraft carrier, ear of wheat, fruit, etc. and a serial number. Some stamps also had alphabetic lettering. The kind and amount of rationed commodities were not specified on most of the stamps and were not defined until later when local newspapers published, for example, that beginning on a specified date, one airplane stamp was required (in addition to cash) to buy one pair of shoes and one stamp number 30 from ration book four was required to buy five pounds of sugar. The commodity amounts changed from time to time depending on availability. Red stamps were used to ration meat and butter, and blue stamps were used to ration processed foods.

To enable making change for ration stamps, the government issued ‘red point’ tokens to be given in change for red stamps, and ‘blue point’ tokens in change for blue stamps. The red and blue tokens were about the size of dimes (16 mm) and were made of thin compressed wood fiber material, because metals were in short supply.” [wikipedia]
In order to make the message communicate a bit more readily than this, a much simpler system would be devised, or they would take the form of coupons that would indicate a specific amount of a resource that would be rationed.
This piece could take the form of a single mailer, or of an entire ration book, complete with instructions on how it is to be used. That might make it harder to understand quickly, but allow for more in depth information to be provided. So aside from the general message, the audience might gain tips for conserving resources now, but in a language and form keeping with the ration book format. In other words, include information directing citizens on steps they can take to make the most of things during ration times. Note: That probably didn’t clear up anything. Oh well.

October 2nd, 2008

Milestone: Phase Two Presentation

For seminar we were asked to present a summation of our Phase Two research and concept development. This presentation uses simple graphic techniques to illustrate the stages the project has progressed so far, as well as featuring some of the most current visual explorations.

CoreVI_Presentation_Phase2_Oct2 (pdf 1.6mb)

Feedback
Well the concept seemed to hold up fairly well, and there were quite a few less blank stares than anticipated. Nelson offered an interesting suggestion. “Why can’t this be a contemporary piece, which projects the subject matter into the future, as opposed to a theoretical piece which existing in the future?” (paraphrasing heavily) The reasoning being, amongst other things, that it’s highly speculative trying to design for an audience that may potentially exist, as opposed to one that can be assessed today.
Thus the revision would be to still have the content of the campaign be a vision of a propagandistic future, but frame it as a warning/premonition for people today. The only difficult part of that to assess would be how far to push the visual language towards the totalitarian, since it would need to be reasonably overt to come through.
Tricky.

September 25th, 2008

Cuban Revolutionary Posters

Lets do our job!
Let’s do our job!
In 1961, Cuban schools close for several months. Students are sent to the countryside in ‘alphabetization brigades’ to teach the population reading and writing. The exercise books are highly political: among the first words taught are ‘Organization of American States’, ‘agrarian reform’ and ‘cooperation’. According to government statistics, contested by others, illiteracy is reduced from 20-25 to 4-5 percent.

Better not to be, than not to be revolutionary
Better not to be, than not to be revolutionary
In the orthodox socialist realist fashion, a slogan like this is illustrated with giant workers and heroic soldiers. Mederos chooses a purely typographic solution, where contrasts of black and white and differences in size are to enhance the meaning of the words. Upper case and lower case letters are mixed.

Setback
Setback
The sugar harvest of 1970 is big, but the desired ten million tons are not obtained. A comforting slogan is introduced: try to turn this setback (’reves’) into a victory (’V’ for ‘victoria’).

September 25th, 2008

Content: Issues Requiring Legislation

A listing of potential topics which the final piece could address. These issues will will/may require legislation to control, and are most likely to have a direct and visible impact on the population at large.

CO2 Emissions
Higher fuel efficiency standards
Greater use of public transport
Alternative transport methods
Emissions caps for industry

Clean Energy Sources
Economic initiatives for use and development
Heavy taxation of “dirty” energy sources (coal, oil, etc)
Localized power development

Excessive Consumerism
Buying according to need rather than want
Buying locally and discouraging unnecessary importation
Regulating product safety and examining lifespan

Conservation of Resources

September 25th, 2008

On a lighter note

Apparently the polar bears aren’t doing too bad after all.

September 25th, 2008

Potential Thesis Revision: Soft Approach

Ten years from now we will be living in a drastically different world than today.
Through the early actions of our society in response to this crisis, we are continuing a constant drive of socially progressive innovation. Resulting from a system of proactive government reforms and a culture of social responsibility we are moving towards a sustainable future. This is supported by letting every citizen know their role and what is expected of them in building this new future.
This is the message of the Eco-Conscious, “Responsibility: The Hallmark of a Bright Future”

September 25th, 2008

Potential Thesis Revision: Hard Approach

Ten years from now we will be living in a drastically different world than today.
Sweeping and drastic reforms will be required from our government to stem the tide of global climate change, mandating a substantial loss of civil liberties. The government will need to instill a new ideology in it’s citizens in order to impose these changes.
This is the message of the New Green Order, “Your Compliance Ensures Our Survival”.

September 18th, 2008

For next time…

The quintessential face of propaganda, George Orwell's omnipresent Big Brother, from the landmark novel of totalitarian dystopianism, 1984
Concept Development
Determine the audience.
Select the key environmental issues to focus on (Plan B)
Determine the application of federal legislation to those issues (Plan B, CBC)

People to Contact
Change Design Done. Meeting tentatively scheduled for Friday afternoon.
Lester Brown (again) Done. No response yet. Email again tomorrow.
The Heritage Moment creators In progress (have to call toronto office)

Further Research Subjects
Goebbels (SS) and Nazi war propaganda, both international and domestic, to see how his department applied techniques. In progress
Prepackaged media promotions of Greenpeace. Still no luck. Emailed Mateesco for references.
Foucault and his writings on surveillance and fear. In progress (reading)
Orwell’s writing and Stalin’s portrayal to see how they used the same figures to apply to multiple audience segments.

Deliverables
Revised proposal with bibliography.
Three basic concept iterations.
Mood boards? Maybe.

September 18th, 2008

Sept 18th: Seminar

Observations
Apparently Heritage Moments (Historica Minutes) have a pretty potent effect, on both a Canadian audience, as well as on impressionable Filipinas. Their propagandistic nature might be debatable, but they definitely serve a purpose in invoking a sense of patriotic pride, in a subtle way. It’s worth noting that part of the reason why the Heritage Moments have found such a deeply rooted place in the psyche of the average Canadian is due to their proliferation across the airways for a number of years.
Part of the reason that they got so much airtime was in fact a result of indirect government intervention. Every broadcaster in Canada is required to show a certain amount of Canadian content in their programming. One hour of Canadian content for every 6 hours of something of the sort. While most of the time it gets counted minute by minute, the Heritage Minutes were counted as 90 seconds or 2 minutes (something like that) of national content, despite their set length of 60 seconds. This allowed broadcasters to use them to meet their content quotas more efficiently.
This sort of “soft propaganda” seems to resonate with Canadians, but in the context of this project, would the a harder approach be more effective in sparking discussions amongst viewers?

Discussion with Alex:
Research into Foucault and his writings on surveillance and fear.
Look at the work of Goebbels (SS) and see how his department applied techniques.
Look at Orwell’s writing and Stalin’s portrayal to see how they used the same figures to apply to multiple audience segments.
Review the prepackaged media promotions of Greenpeace.
Consider the media that will be used, and it applicability to the audience.
Contact the people who made the Heritage Moments to get some insights into the format they used.